|
Icons (the word for "images" in both the Greek
Old and New Testaments) are honored as reminders of the glory and
presence of God, and venerated as such. Worship belongs only
to God: the Father, Jesus Christ the Word, and the Holy Spirit.
Just as we recognize that Man is made in the image [icon] of Christ,
and so we show honor to one another - in the same way we acknowledge
that God is represented in all His creation. Even further, we believe
that, since Christ has entered creation and has become material,
He has made matter itself holy; so material things are fit to be
used to worship and depict Him.
Rather than attempting
a natural or artistic depiction, icons point to the realities of
the Kingdom of God. They are often referred to as "picture windows
to Heaven". In other words, you will not only hear the Gospel in
an Orthodox Church, you will see it. (And smell it, and touch and
taste.) Icons are tools in our spiritual worship, and they bear
witness to the sanctification of all creation and matter
that occurred when Christ Jesus, the Son of God, took on human nature.
Jesus in the Incarnation became the living icon of God in the flesh
(John 10:30; 14:6-11).
Still,
aren't images a violation of the Second Commandment?
It might be worth another look at the text: What God actually forbade was the making
of graven images of anything in heaven or earth, for the purpose
of worshipping them. Here's His actual command:
You shall not make for yourself a carved image, or any likeness of
anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth
beneath, or that is in the water under the earth; you shall
not bow down to them nor serve them. For I, the LORD your God,
am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the
children to the third and fourth generations of those who hate
Me, but showing mercy to thousands, to those who love Me and
keep My commandments. (Exodus 20:4,5).
If this passage prohibits pictures of the incarnate Christ,
or of angels or our heroes in the Faith, then at the same time we're
tearing down all the Bible flannelgraphs in our Sunday School rooms,
we really ought to destroy our photos of our families, snapshots
of pets or the Grand Canyon, and the Statue of Liberty... Those
are all images of things in the heaven or earth or water. In reality,
of course, no one but the Muslims really believes that God meant
to prohibit all images of anything in heaven or earth; it's the
worshipping of images that He forbids.
Then
why do Orthodox Christians kiss icons? Isn't that worshipping them?
To modern Americans,
unaccustomed to expressing honor physically, it might look that
way. But it's worth noting that this kind of veneration isn't unique
to Orthodox Christianity: Many Orthodox Jews kiss the mezuzah on
their doorpost as they pass it; they kiss their tallenin, too, as
they put them on (Deuteronomy 6:8,9). Orthodox Jews kiss the Torah before reading it in the synagogue,
as Jesus must have done. Orthodox Christians likewise kiss the book
of the Gospels in reverence when we read it, since it is the premier
verbal icon of Christ. (See
this Jewish explanation of kissing things in devotion.)
In many cultures outside
the Western world, there is nothing strange about bowing to greet
someone; in Mediterranean and Slavic cultures it's common to greet
friends and honored guests with a hug and kisses on both cheeks,
as Scripture repeatedly says, "Greet one another with a holy kiss"
(Romans 16:16; 1 Corinthians
16:20; 2 Corinthians 13:12; 1 Thessalonians 5:26). It's worth speculating as to whether that
greeting with a kiss came to Christianity from the hearty Mediterranean
cultures, or whether those cultures learned it from the Christians.
Either way, culture and spirituality affect one another deeply.
Perhaps if we as a Western culture were more in tune with the middle-eastern
sensibilities of the New Testament writers, we would have less aversion
to honoring one another with kisses and bowing; and then we would
be much less put off by the ways in which Christians show honor
to other living Christians who are no longer living in the body.
We ought to distinguish
between worship, which is for God alone, and honor,
which we owe to kings
(1 Peter 2:7), presbyters
(1 Tim 5:17), wives
(1 Peter 3:7), and indeed to all people
(1 Peter 2:17),
since all are in the image [icon] of Christ.
We bow to honor one another and to honor our heroes in the Faith
who are depicted in icons. We greet all the saints
(Hebrews 13:24) with
a holy kiss ...including the saints who are represented in the Bible
and in icons. After all, there isn't a great chasm fixed
between the living and the dead. That gulf lies between the righteous
and the wicked (Luke 16:26), not between us
and the living Christians who are "absent from the body and present
with the Lord." Christ doesn't have two Bodies, one on earth and
one in heaven; His Body the Church is one, and
includes both us who are in the body and the "great cloud of witnesses"
(Heb 12:1).
But there
weren't any images in the Tabernacle or the Temple.
Sure there were! Anyone
who's read much of the Old Testament will probably recognize the
phrase "golden calf". Aaron set up a golden calf and told Israel
"This is your God who brought you out of Egypt!" In later generations,
Israel's default design for an idol was a bull or calf. This was
an image that had strong resonance for them - this is what a god
"looked like" to their religious sensibilities. (For comparison,
see all the Assyrian and Babylonian images of "cherubim" i.e. human-headed,
winged bulls.) Prophets cried out against the worship of the golden
calves; God pronounced judgments on those who set up these images
for worship.
So what would you say if I told you these images
were set up in the Temple - with God's approval?
It may be startling (to say the least) to read
in 1 Kings 7:25 that the brazen sea - the huge 15-foot diameter
basin in the courts of the Temple - was made with graven images
of twelve bulls prominently displayed. This should tell us,
if nothing else, that God is not displeased by the presence of pictorial
representations in holy places. Even when, as in this case, they
are graven images identical to those the Israelites periodically
worshipped!
Of course those weren't the only graven images
in the Temple. You'll also find:
- Two fifteen-foot-tall cherubim in the Holy of Holies
(1 Kings 6:23-28)
- All the Temple's inside walls were covered with carved figures
of cherubim, palm trees, and open flowers.
(1 Kings 6:29)
- The doors of the sanctuary and of the inner sanctuary were
carved gold-overlaid images of cherubim, palm trees, and flowers
(1 Kings 6:32,34)
- On the Temple carts, images of bulls and lions.
(1 Kings 7:29,36)
- and of course the two cherubs
on top of the Ark itself!
God sees the difference
between graven images in general, and graven images to which one
gives worship. Hopefully we can too.
In fact, God has commissioned
a number of icons. He commanded Moses to display an icon in Numbers
21:8,9 - God healed the Israelites from snakebite when they looked
to the icon of the snake. It was not until a later generation, when
the people had named this icon Nehushtan and worshipped it as a
god, that it was necessary to destroy it
(2 Kings 18:4). At
another time, God specifically commanded Ezekiel to paint an icon
of the city of Jerusalem and to treat the icon as a symbol of Jerusalem
(Ezekiel 4:1ff).
We certainly can't theorize
that images are foreign to Biblical prayer and piety. Modern iconoclasm
was not a feature of ancient Judaism, nor are images automatically
idols. (Which is not to say that abuses never occur, as with the
divinely-appointed icon that later became the idol Nehushtan.)
I've visited Jewish
synagogues, and I know for a fact that they don't display images
like the ones in an Orthodox Church. Who changed?
The Jews did. Certainly
modern synagogues don't display images as an Orthodox Church building
does. But New Testament-era Jews had no qualms about lavishly decorating
their synagogues with images of biblical figures. When the second-century
synagogue
at Dura Europos in modern Syria was unearthed, the wall-paintings
were found in excellent condition. Here are thumbnail photos of
the back wall and the tabernacle area of the synagogue
| (Click
below for larger view!) |
 |
 |
Modern Jewish practice
notwithstanding, it's entirely appropriate to display representations
of things heavenly or earthly, at home or in the sanctuary. It's
not the presence of images that's wrong; what God rightly forbids
is the worship of images. And the Orthodox Church, while
using icons as tools in prayer, has always vigorously condemned
idolatry in all forms. While it may look like we're worshipping
icons, trust us: We know the difference.
|